David Ibarra teaches his first class to a group of both clueless and rambunctious students. Ravien, Maxima, Twerp, Penny, Ernst, Nathaniel, Hugo, Nikki, and Naomi all take turns trying to come up with a solution to his supposed problem. They all must tell him how to make a Nutella Sandwich.
The attempts start off horrible, as Hugo makes him rub the jar on top of an unopened loaf. Ravien tries to outsmart the teacher by giving a proper answer but David is one step ahead and tricks her into thinking the bread is unsliced. Nikki then attempts to give it a shot, and the bread ends up as an art piece rather than a sandwich.
Then it’s Nathaniel’s turn. Slowly but surely the others guide him in the right direction. Ernst’s hands are in a death grip at his table as the final step approaches. Before Nathaniel can finish, Naomi walks to the front of the class and puts the sandwich together herself. The solution has been reached!
The excited class’s celebration is cut short when Big Arm arrives to greet David and tell the class to quiet down. Class ends with David’s career up in the air.